Comments on: #InfographicInspiration: What Do Robots Think? https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/ English 3764 @ Virginia Tech, Spring 2018 Thu, 12 Apr 2018 20:39:57 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.2 By: Moqi Zhang https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2277 Mon, 16 Apr 2018 17:06:26 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2277 This article is really helpful. Before I read this article, I didn’t know some companies use the robot to read my resume. That is why I never heard back from employer sometimes. I think I need rewrite my resume, am put every keyword on the top of the page, and use the web-standard font. From the last article, I knew that we can use a website called Canva to format my resume, which helps me make a format that robot can read.

]]>
By: Clement Boateng https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2274 Mon, 16 Apr 2018 14:37:01 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2274 I do agree with Danielle on this one. I have not actually thought about this in the past. It makes sense that huge companies use technology to filter applications. However, these technologies use certain keywords to do the filtering, and that is not fair because a perfect fit for the job may not not have those needed keywords on their resume. The only thing I may disagree with is the use of PDF. I have worked with few recruiters for my company who highly recommend submitting resume in a PDF format. This is because using others like Microsoft word can mess up the formatting when it is opened on other computers. With a PDF, the format stays as it is, and it is compatible with every other computer.

]]>
By: Yibo Xu https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2271 Mon, 16 Apr 2018 01:49:09 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2271 It’s my first time hear something about the ATS system and it’s my first time think about this. I wrote my resume basically based on human-eyes, such as in the career fair, I hand my resumes to employers to read my resume. But I submitted the same resume online as well. It might be the problem that sometimes I feel like a clear and well organized resume with a little fancy style is good to read, but online, it may have bad influence. But to be honest, I don’t really like this system since it’s a ‘robot’ control system, systems can’t read the whole information or adjust the wrong information. Employer who read this resume sometimes could have emotions in reading the information but robots never have that.

]]>
By: Michael Severance https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2267 Sun, 15 Apr 2018 16:16:34 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2267 After reading this, I definitely understand the need for robot resume screening more. If big companies like Google really are getting 75000 applications in one week, it would be impossible to manually filter through those. Unfortunately, I think using robots to filter resumes can cause a company to miss many promising candidates. For example, if a robot was programmed to filter our resumes based on their GPA, they will miss a valuable candidate who might have a lower GPA but makes up for it with personal projects and work experience. While I understand the need for robots in job recruiting, right now I still think a human can do a better job.

]]>
By: Casey https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2263 Sat, 14 Apr 2018 14:00:16 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2263 This is mostly the case for job markets that are over-saturated with candidates (where hundreds or thousands of people apply to a position). In my experience, it’s better to either seek out specialized markets where there is far less competition (and therefore no benefit to computerized resume filtering) or, better yet, bypass the resume filtering stage altogether via networking.

Especially valuable is networking that demonstrates your skill since it makes you more of a known quantity and less of a risk. The hiring process is mostly about risk management, and due to expense of ramping up new employees and social pressures (and often the sunk cost fallacy) against firing those that don’t turn out as valuable as expected, companies are very risk-averse in the hiring stage. They strongly prefer precision in identifying valuable candidates over recall or accuracy, and will happily filter out many strong candidates as long as it means they never (or rarely) make a bad hire.

But all that aside, I think the bulk of your job-application effort should be spent on developing new skills and capabilities, especially really general ones that will serve you for your entire career, rather than tweaking the marketing materials you use to sell yourself (i.e. resume, etc). For software engineers, this means learning architecture design, writing, project management, etc. rather than learning just the hot new programming language or framework. Having a broad range of generalizable skills will make everything about this process so much easier, and ensure that you never end up being the bad hire that employers worry about.

]]>
By: Katie https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2260 Sat, 14 Apr 2018 01:09:13 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2260 I still think that a one page resume is best when you know your application is being read by a human. But with robots? I was just like you, I had no idea! I also usually submit my resume as a PDF to preserve formatting, so I think I’ll invest some time into making a simplistically formatted resume that is robot friendly–and take out my headers/footers, because I have both in my resume (whoops!).

]]>
By: Yoonjin Kim https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2254 Fri, 13 Apr 2018 20:52:00 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2254 I am quite surprise about the fact that only 35% of the applicants meet the requirements. Yes I do agree that there are some people who just glanced at the application and apply no matter what the requirements are. So, I am aware that automatic Application Tracking Systems are getting necessary to find the possible candidate. I would say the most idealistic way would that every candidate has universally formatted profile by adding the specific features(ex, majors, computer languages, skills) set to pass the “requirements” threshold and also provide personal and readable resumes in PDF in human computer interaction friendly format. I know that Virginia Tech Piazza support this kind of procedure that you can add the tags into your profile and you can submit PDF version of resume after automatically checking your tags from the profile.

]]>
By: Carolina Martyn https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2249 Thu, 12 Apr 2018 20:39:57 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2249 Although I understand the purpose of tailoring your resume so that robots could read it, most large companies have forms you must fill out to apply, so I don’t really see the point in changing the format of my resume. Maybe I would consider putting more information on the forms to set myself apart from my competitors, but, at least in my experience, employers probably won’t see the resume unless the information on the application form is appealing.

]]>
By: Mariel Jastrebsky https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2247 Thu, 12 Apr 2018 19:14:45 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2247 I totally agree with what you are saying. I never realized that robots read the applications, and that the length of the resume doesn’t matter. I was always taught to keep a resume at around 1 page or less. However, it would make sense that having more information on a document would entice the ATS to read through it. I also didn’t realize that having tables or graphics deter the ATS because for people, the more visual something is, the more inclined they are to read it.

]]>
By: Matthew Erwin https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/infographicinspiration-what-do-robots-think/#comment-2246 Thu, 12 Apr 2018 18:40:37 +0000 https://3764s18.tracigardner.com/?p=4937#comment-2246 I have been putting a ton of application out lately and never even thought of how a robot could be filtering my applications out. That is a little unnerving and aggravating. As others have said, we invest a lot of time and effort into our resumes, and to just be passed up by a robot and never have human eyes view it, its just unethical like Kristina said. For me, it kind of goes back to hard GPA requirements companies have. For instance, some require a 3.0, and if you have anything less, they wont even consider you (That would even be a really easy way for ATSs to filter applications). But that GPA does not accurately represent work ethic, who you are, or maybe even personal issues that have unfortunately come up during exams or anything. I was a little taken back by the mention of not following the 1-page convention. Everything we have always learned about resume formatting is to always stay within 1-page. But we’ve also learned to appeal to human eyes, not to ATSs. So I guess it is time to revise my resume for ATSs.

]]>